SHOW TOPICS
Baroque painting of the Holy Spirit as a dove descending upon Mary and the apostles at Pentecost in Jerusalem.

The breath, the wind, the flame and the dove: the person Christians find hardest to picture

Ask almost anyone to picture God the Father and an image arrives: an old man, a voice, a light. Ask for the Son and there is a face, a man walking on the shore of Galilee. Ask for the Spirit and most people hesitate. Then they reach for something that moves: a bird, a wind, a flame. The hesitation is not ignorance. It is close to what the Bible itself does. The Spirit is almost never described. He is shown by what he does.

The Holy Spirit appears in the second verse of the Bible and in the last chapter of Revelation, and in nearly every book between. He is also the part of the Christian faith that is most often reduced to a feeling, a force or a vague presence. The New Testament says something more definite, and so do the Churches. This guide follows the Spirit through Scripture, from creation to the upper room in Jerusalem, and then sets out, honestly, where Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant Christians agree and where they do not. For how all of this shapes an ordinary Christian life, see our wider guide to what it means to live as a Christian.

The Holy Spirit is the third person of the Holy Trinity: God himself, equal with the Father and the Son, who gives life, inspired the prophets and Scripture, and dwells in believers. Christians confess him in the Nicene Creed as Lord and giver of life. He is not an impersonal force, and he is not a lesser being: the Church has taught from the fourth century that he is worshipped together with the Father and the Son.

Who the Holy Spirit Is

The words themselves carry a clue. The Hebrew word ruach and the Greek pneuma both mean wind, breath and spirit at once. Jesus plays on exactly this in his night conversation with Nicodemus: the wind blows where it wills, and you hear it without seeing where it comes from, and so it is with everyone born of the Spirit (John 3:5–8). The name suggests something real that can be felt in its effects and cannot be held.

But the New Testament does not leave the Spirit as a mere image. He is spoken of as someone. In Antioch the Holy Spirit tells the church to set apart Barnabas and Saul for a task (Acts 13:2). Paul says the Spirit distributes gifts as he wills (1 Corinthians 12:11), intercedes for believers with groanings too deep for words (Romans 8:26), and can be grieved (Ephesians 4:30). When Ananias lies to the apostles, Peter says he has lied to the Holy Spirit, and in the next breath, that he has lied to God (Acts 5:3–4). Jesus tells his disciples to baptize in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, one name, three persons (Matthew 28:19). The Catechism of the Catholic Church puts the Church's belief in one sentence: to believe in the Holy Spirit is to profess that he is one of the persons of the Trinity, one in being with the Father and the Son (CCC 685). That equal honour is why Christians give him the same praise they give the Father and the Son in the short doxology many pray daily, which our guide to the Glory Be prayer traces back to the earliest Church.

↑ Back to top

The Spirit Within the Trinity

The Council of Nicaea in 325 affirmed the divinity of the Son, although the controversy continued for decades, and its creed said almost nothing about the Spirit beyond a bare statement of belief in him. Within a generation that was no longer enough. Athanasius of Alexandria, writing from exile around 359 to 361, answered Christians who held that the Spirit was a creature, a kind of exalted angel, by arguing that the Spirit cannot be separated from the Father and the Son. At the Council of Constantinople in 381 the creed was expanded to confess the Spirit as Lord and giver of life, worshipped and glorified together with the Father and the Son, and as the one who spoke through the prophets. The creed Christians recite at Sunday worship is, in this form, the Creed of 381. The story of the first council is told in our article on the Council of Nicaea.

The Church was slow to name the Spirit because he was slow to be known. Gregory of Nazianzus, quoted in the Catechism, explained that God taught in stages: the Father first, then the Son, and only then, openly, the Spirit, so that the light of the Trinity could grow brighter as the disciples were able to bear it (CCC 684). The older and shorter creed of the Roman Church speaks of the Spirit in a single line, set out in our guide to the Apostles' Creed. A full treatment of the Trinity belongs to its own article; here the point is simply that the Spirit is not an afterthought in Christian belief. He is part of how Christians understand who God is.

↑ Back to top

The Spirit in the Old Testament

"And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters."

— Genesis 1:2 (KJV)

In Genesis the Hebrew ruach elohim can be understood as the Spirit of God, the wind of God or a mighty wind, depending on the translation and interpretation. Christian tradition has long read this verse as the Spirit present at creation, with the Father working through the Word in the Spirit. The same biblical imagery of divine breath returns when God gives life to the first human being (Genesis 2:7) and when Ezekiel is told to call breath into a valley of dry bones until they stand up as a great army (Ezekiel 37:1–14).

Across the Old Testament the Spirit comes upon particular people for particular tasks, and usually for a time. He rushes on David when Samuel anoints him with oil (1 Samuel 16:13). He fills the craftsman Bezalel with skill, understanding and knowledge to build the tabernacle, which is one of the Bible's quiet reminders that handwork can be a work of the Spirit (Exodus 31:1–5). He speaks through the prophets, which is why the Creed says he has spoken through the prophets. David, after his great sin, prays that God will not take his holy spirit from him (Psalm 51:11).

Then the prophets begin to promise something larger. Isaiah sees a shoot from the stump of Jesse on whom the Spirit will rest in fullness (Isaiah 11:1–3). Joel hears God promise to pour out his Spirit on all flesh, on sons and daughters, on old and young, even on servants (Joel 2:28–29). The Old Testament does not use the language of Trinity, and Jewish readers do not read these texts that way. Christians read them in the light of Jesus and Pentecost, and believe the promises were kept.

↑ Back to top

The Spirit in the Life of Jesus

In the Gospels the Spirit and Jesus are never apart. The angel tells Mary in Nazareth that the Holy Spirit will come upon her and the power of the Most High will overshadow her, and so the child will be holy, the Son of God (Luke 1:35). Tradition remembers the place in the grotto beneath the basilica of the Church of the Annunciation in Nazareth. Before that, Luke says John the Baptist would be filled with the Holy Spirit from his mother's womb (Luke 1:15), the beginning of a life described in our article on who John the Baptist was.

The Annunciation, with the Archangel Gabriel appearing to the Virgin Mary in Nazareth as the Holy Spirit descends from heaven.

The Spirit's most famous appearance in Jesus' life is at the Jordan. When Jesus comes up out of the water, the heavens open and the Spirit descends on him like a dove, while a voice from heaven names him the beloved Son (Matthew 3:16–17). Luke adds that the Spirit came in bodily form, and John records the Baptist's testimony that he saw the Spirit descend and remain on Jesus (Luke 3:22; John 1:32–33). The place where Christians remember it is described in our guide to the Jordan River and its Christian meaning.

Jesus is baptized by John the Baptist in the Jordan River as the Holy Spirit descends and angels look on.

From then on the Gospels say everything Jesus does is done in the Spirit. He is led by the Spirit into the wilderness and returns in the power of the Spirit to Galilee (Luke 4:1, 14). In the synagogue at Nazareth he reads Isaiah's words, the Spirit of the Lord is upon me, and says they are fulfilled that day (Luke 4:18–21). The very word Christ means anointed, and the Catechism notes that the Son's humanity was anointed entirely by the Holy Spirit (CCC 695).

↑ Back to top

The Paraclete: What Jesus Promised

At the Last Supper, as Jesus prepares his friends for his death, he promises not to leave them alone. He will ask the Father, and the Father will give them another Paraclete to be with them forever (John 14:16). The Greek paraklētos means one called alongside, and English translations disagree about how to render it: Comforter, Advocate, Helper, Counselor. Each captures part of it.

"But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance, whatsoever I have said unto you."

— John 14:26 (KJV)

The Paraclete has work to do. He teaches and reminds (John 14:26), testifies about Jesus (John 15:26), convicts the world about sin, righteousness and judgment (John 16:8), and guides the disciples into all truth, speaking not on his own but what he hears (John 16:13). The Catechism draws out the last point: the Spirit does not call attention to himself. He makes Christ known, which is why the Church knows him chiefly through the Scriptures he inspired, the Tradition, the liturgy and prayer (CCC 687–688).

On the evening of Easter, the risen Jesus breathes on his disciples and says, receive the Holy Spirit, then speaks of forgiving and retaining sins (John 20:22–23). It is the same breath as in Genesis. The Gospels also record Jesus' solemn warning about blasphemy against the Spirit (Mark 3:28–30), which our article on what the Bible says about forgiveness explains in context.

↑ Back to top

Pentecost: The Day the Spirit Came

Forty days after Easter, Jesus is taken up from the Mount of Olives while the disciples watch, having told them they will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes upon them and will be his witnesses in Jerusalem, in Judea, in Samaria and to the ends of the earth (Acts 1:8–12). Pilgrims still visit the place, now remembered in the Chapel of the Ascension on the Mount of Olives. The disciples go back to the city, to the upper room, and wait (Acts 1:13–14).

The day they were waiting for was already a feast. Pentecost means fiftieth: it was the Jewish feast that came seven weeks after Passover, when Israel brought the first fruits of the harvest to Jerusalem (Leviticus 23:15–21). Luke says they were all together in one place when a sound like a rushing wind filled the house, and what looked like tongues of fire rested on each of them, and they began to speak in other languages as the Spirit gave them utterance (Acts 2:1–4). Pilgrims from every nation heard their own languages spoken (Acts 2:5–11). Many Christian writers have seen here a reversal of Babel, where languages were confused (Genesis 11); Acts itself does not say so, but the contrast is hard to miss.

Peter stands up and explains what is happening, quoting Joel's promise of the Spirit poured out on all flesh. He calls the crowd to repent and be baptized for the forgiveness of sins and promises that they too will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit (Acts 2:14–38). About three thousand are baptized that day (Acts 2:41). The Catechism says that on this day the Holy Trinity is fully revealed, and Christians have long treated it as the beginning of the Church (CCC 731–732). Our guide to the meaning of Easter traces the fifty days from the Resurrection to Pentecost. The date of Pentecost changes each year according to the date of Easter, and Western and Eastern Orthodox calendars do not always coincide.

Where did it happen? Acts says that the disciples gathered in an upper room after the Ascension (Acts 1:13) and that they were all together in one place when Pentecost came (Acts 2:1). It does not explicitly identify the two rooms as the same place or give an address. Christian tradition places both the Last Supper and Pentecost in the Cenacle on Mount Zion, just outside the walls of today's Old City, and the Franciscan Custody of the Holy Land presents it as exactly that: the place tradition holds to be both. The Gothic hall visitors enter today is a medieval building, not a first-century room, and the Franciscans received the site in the fourteenth century. Each Pentecost they walk in procession through the city to the upper room and pray there. Whether the New Testament room stood on this exact spot cannot be proved, and the Custody speaks of tradition, not proof. The room itself, its Crusader hall and its shared custody, is described in our guide to the Cenacle on Mount Zion The Cenacle belongs to the wider story of the Holy Land, told in our complete guide to the Holy Land.

Interior of the Cenacle on Mount Zion in Jerusalem, traditionally associated with Pentecost and the Last Supper.

What the first Christians did next, with their life together in Jerusalem, the debate over Gentile believers and Paul's mission, is followed in our article on how Christianity began.

↑ Back to top

Symbols of the Spirit

Because the Spirit has no face in Scripture, the Bible and the Church's tradition reach for images. The Catechism names several (CCC 694–701), and the New Testament supplies others. Each points at something different he does.

Symbol Where it appears What it points to
Water John 3:5; the baptism of Jesus New birth and fruitfulness; the Spirit at work in baptism (CCC 694)
Oil and anointing 1 Samuel 16:13; Luke 4:18 Being set apart and strengthened; "Christ" itself means the anointed one (CCC 695)
Fire Luke 3:16; Acts 2:3 The transforming energy of the Spirit's action (CCC 696)
Wind and breath John 3:8; John 20:22; Acts 2:2 Life given and power that cannot be seen or controlled
Cloud and light Luke 1:35; Luke 9:34; Acts 1:9 God's presence that both reveals and veils (CCC 697)
Seal John 6:27; Ephesians 1:13 A lasting mark of belonging (CCC 698)
Hand Mark 6:5; Acts 8:17 Healing, blessing, and the giving of the Spirit by the laying on of hands (CCC 699)
Dove Matthew 3:16; Genesis 8:11 A new beginning; the Spirit descending on Christ (CCC 701)

The dove is the symbol most people know, and it has a longer story than the Jordan. After the flood, Noah sends a dove out of the ark, and it returns in the evening with a freshly plucked olive leaf, a sign that the earth was habitable again (Genesis 8:11). The Catechism sets that dove beside the one at Jesus' baptism, reading both as signs of a new beginning (CCC 701). Christian art has long shown the Spirit as a dove. For Christians who want a small reminder of it, our olive wood Holy Spirit dove cross necklace, handcrafted in Bethlehem with an engraved descending dove, is one way to carry it; a round medallion with a raised dove is also available in the same range.

Olive wood Holy Spirit cross necklace with engraved dove, black braided cord and gold loop

Water has its own place, because in the Church's teaching the Spirit is given in baptism: Jesus tells Nicodemus that no one enters the kingdom without being born of water and the Spirit (John 3:5), and Paul writes that God saved us through the washing of rebirth and renewal by the Holy Spirit (Titus 3:5). What that means in practice differs a little between traditions, and our guide to what baptism is describes the rite and its meaning.

↑ Back to top

Gifts, Fruits and Spiritual Gifts

Three terms are often mixed up, and each has a different home in Scripture. The gifts of the Spirit grow from Isaiah's picture of the Messiah. The fruits come from Paul's letter to the Galatians. The spiritual gifts, sometimes called charisms, come from his letters to Corinth and Rome.

Term Where it comes from What it describes
Seven gifts Isaiah 11:2–3; CCC 1830–1831 Lasting dispositions that make a person ready to follow the Spirit: wisdom, understanding, counsel, fortitude, knowledge, piety and fear of the Lord. The Catechism says they belong in their fullness to Christ.
Fruits Galatians 5:22–23; CCC 1832 The character the Spirit forms. Paul names nine: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. Catholic tradition lists twelve.
Spiritual gifts (charisms) 1 Corinthians 12:4–11; Romans 12:6–8 Varied abilities given for the good of the whole community, such as teaching, service, encouragement and healing.

Catholics associate the seven gifts especially with Confirmation, the sacrament in which, in the Church's teaching, the Spirit strengthens the baptized. Our article on what Catholic Confirmation is covers the rite, the oil and what the sacrament accomplishes. The fixed list of seven is the Catholic and Western way of counting the gifts in Isaiah 11; other traditions read the same passage but do not necessarily use the same list.

The fruits are the test of the rest. Paul sets them against the works of the flesh and notes that against such things there is no law, and the difference is plain in daily life: a gift can be admired, and a fruit can only be lived. Spiritual gifts in the Pauline sense are about the shape of a congregation, and one image runs through them: one body, many members, each needed. How that applies to money, time and talents is discussed in our guide to Christian stewardship.

↑ Back to top

How the Churches Speak of the Spirit

All the major Christian traditions confess the Holy Spirit as God and as a person. They differ on emphasis and on one disputed word in the Creed. The table sets out what each tradition's own authorities say; it is a summary, not a full account, and the Oriental Orthodox churches (Coptic, Armenian, Syriac and others) have their own authorities and are not covered here.

Tradition What it stresses Source
Catholic The Spirit is one of the three divine persons, worshipped with the Father and the Son; Pentecost fully reveals the Trinity. The Latin Creed says the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son. Catechism 685, 731–732; Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, 1995
Eastern Orthodox The Father is the sole source of the Spirit. The Creed is said without "and the Son," and the Church calls Pentecost the beginning of the Christian Church. Orthodox Church in America
Anglican The Holy Ghost is of one substance, majesty and glory with the Father and the Son, and proceeds from both. Thirty-Nine Articles, Article V
Lutheran and Reformed Faith itself is the Spirit's work: Luther confesses that he cannot believe by his own strength and that the Spirit calls through the Gospel; the Westminster Confession calls faith the work of the Spirit of Christ in the heart, ordinarily through the Word. Luther's Small Catechism; Westminster Confession 14.1
Pentecostal The Assemblies of God teaches baptism in the Holy Spirit as an experience distinct from and after conversion, with speaking in tongues as its initial physical sign (Acts 2:4). Other Pentecostal churches differ in how they describe this experience and its evidence. Assemblies of God, Statement of Fundamental Truths

The disputed word is Filioque, Latin for "and the Son." The Greek Creed of 381 says the Spirit proceeds from the Father. As the creed was translated and used in the Latin West, the words "and the Son" were added, and the addition entered Latin liturgical use gradually. The Orthodox Church regards it as an unacceptable doctrinal addition. In 1995, at Pope John Paul II's request, the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity published a clarification. It explains that the Greek ekporeusis, used in the Creed, means the Spirit's origin from the Father alone as the source of the Trinity, while the Latin processio is a wider word, and says the Catholic Church recognises the Greek Creed of 381 as normative and irrevocable. The two churches have not resolved the question, but the document records how each side can understand what the other means.

How this and other disputes came to divide Eastern and Western Christianity is told in our article on the Great Schism.

The Pentecostal row is worth a word of care. Many Christians outside the Pentecostal churches, including Catholic and Orthodox believers, hold that the Spirit gives gifts of many kinds, and do not teach that speaking in tongues is the required sign of having received him. That is a real difference, and the tradition's own statement of it is the best place to read it.

↑ Back to top

The Spirit in Daily Christian Life

For many Christians, the Spirit is not only a subject of doctrine. They seek his help in prayer that is hard to start, difficult decisions and the call to care for others. Such experiences, however, are not by themselves proof of divine guidance. The New Testament names several ordinary ways he works. No one can say that Jesus is Lord except by the Holy Spirit (1 Corinthians 12:3). When we do not know how to pray, the Spirit prays in us (Romans 8:26), and he is the one who lets believers call God Abba, Father (Romans 8:14–16). Paul calls the Christian body a temple of the Holy Spirit (1 Corinthians 6:19), and Jesus promised that the Father gives the Holy Spirit to those who ask (Luke 11:13).

The same New Testament is sober about discernment. John tells believers not to trust every spirit but to test them (1 John 4:1–3), and Paul's own test is the fruit: love, joy, peace and the rest (Galatians 5:22–23). The traditions differ on how much weight to give a private sense of guidance. The Catechism's answer is that the Spirit is known in Scripture, in Tradition and in the Church's liturgy and prayer, so a feeling that contradicts them is not to be trusted. Many Protestants would say the same about Scripture. No tradition teaches that a sense of being led settles the matter by itself.

Prayer is where this becomes practical. The quiet forms of prayer, in which a person stops speaking and simply waits on God, are described in our article on contemplative prayer. For words to start with, our Christian Prayer Library has a page of prayers to the Holy Spirit.

↑ Back to top

References & Sources

↑ Back to top

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Holy Spirit a person or a force?

The Christian churches teach that the Holy Spirit is a person, the third person of the Trinity and fully God. The New Testament shows him speaking, teaching, interceding and being grieved (Acts 13:2; John 14:26; Romans 8:26; Ephesians 4:30), and Peter treats lying to the Holy Spirit as lying to God (Acts 5:3-4).

What is the difference between the Holy Spirit and the Holy Ghost?

There is no difference in meaning: both translate the same Greek and Latin words, and "Ghost" is simply an older English word for "spirit." The King James Version and traditional prayers such as the Apostles' Creed in older wording use "Holy Ghost," while most modern translations say "Holy Spirit."

What are the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit?

The Catholic Church lists them as wisdom, understanding, counsel, fortitude, knowledge, piety and fear of the Lord, drawing on Isaiah 11:2-3 (Catechism 1831). Catholics associate them especially with Confirmation, and the Catechism says they belong in their fullness to Christ.

What are the fruits of the Holy Spirit?

In Galatians 5:22-23 Paul names nine: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. Catholic tradition, following the Latin text, lists twelve (Catechism 1832).

Why is the Holy Spirit shown as a dove?

At the baptism of Jesus in the Jordan, all four Gospels describe the Spirit descending on him like a dove (Matthew 3:16; Mark 1:10; Luke 3:22; John 1:32). The Catechism also sets this beside Noah's dove returning with an olive leaf after the flood (Genesis 8:11).

How do you receive the Holy Spirit?

Most Christians teach that the Spirit is given in baptism and through faith, and Jesus said the Father gives the Holy Spirit to those who ask (Acts 2:38; Luke 11:13). Churches differ on the role of Confirmation, the laying on of hands and a separate experience of Spirit baptism, as the comparison above shows.

↑ Back to top

↑ Back to top

Closing Reflection

Anyone who reaches for a wind or a flame when asked to picture the Spirit is not far wrong. The Bible gives no face, only a breath over dark water, a bird at a river, a sound in a room in Jerusalem. What it gives instead is a promise: that he would be with us, and that he would remind us of everything Jesus said. On Mount Zion there is a stone hall that no one can prove stood on the exact spot, and the friars still walk up to it every year. They go because the thing that happened there did not stay there. It is still asked for, quietly, in kitchens and hospital corridors and churches, by people who have no words ready. The Spirit has always met them without one.